Hunnibunni1981, I love your signature.

x

I thought he was so harsh!

But I tell you, the night they sang 500 Miles and got good comments from him, I was running around like a 5year old I was so happy for them

Haha. I wouldn't really like to say anything to him, I think they've proved him wrong.

Well i can remeber when he said 2 the lads u need 2 be moreconfidnt  nd i was lyk how can sum1 be confident wen u r in****ing their performance

so he don't deserve the chair

I think that Simon should think about judging on shows like X-factor, because he obviously doesnt know talent even when it hits him in the face. Louis had every faith in the boys he knew that they could do it. Simon should think beore he speaks and take the time to listen to what people have to say before judging them. I agree with others Simons commentsmake the boys more determined to prove him wrong and they have. 

I totally agree with you...they are lovely lovely guys who didn't deserve to get all that critisism...and i think Simon would be kicking himself now when he sees how well they are doing and how popular they are!